Melbourne Property Investment: Is Victoria's Election a Turning Point?
Melbourne property investment is one of the most debated topics in Australian real estate right now. With Victorians heading to the polls at the end of the month, the question is whether a change of government could brighten the outlook for a market that has been left behind.
I invest in Melbourne, and I think it offers real value, along with real trade-offs. Here is how I see the market, why it has stalled, and what the election could mean for investors.
Why Melbourne Property Has Fallen Behind
Over the last five years, Melbourne has basically not grown. Sydney has managed a little growth, while Brisbane, Adelaide and Perth have grown exponentially, from the start of COVID right up until the current correction.
The difference shows up in household wealth. Over those five years, homeowners in Perth gained around half a million dollars, and Adelaide and Brisbane owners about $400,000. Sydney owners gained over $100,000. In Melbourne, owning a home has left people with little to show for it, and probably a step backwards.
The Equity Problem
With no equity growth, people can't use their property to upgrade. Unless they have owned for 10, 15 or 20 years, they have to use their wages and personal savings instead. When growth returns, equity returns with it, and people start using that equity to move up. That creates a capital flow effect.
Where Melbourne Sits on the Price Scoreboard
On median house prices, the ranking is Sydney, Brisbane, Perth, Adelaide, Canberra, and then Melbourne in sixth spot. That doesn't make sense to me. You would expect Melbourne to sit closer to Brisbane, and markets are not typically this far apart in value.
This is also why I recommend owning a portfolio across Australia. There is usually one major market doing well at any given time, which keeps your personal wealth growing. If you only own in Melbourne, that isn't the case.
What Broke Melbourne's Recovery
Melbourne's recovery has been broken more than once. In 2019 and early 2020 there were strong auction clearances and prices were starting to grow. Then COVID hit, and Victoria's lockdowns were especially hostile to the market.
There were green shoots again, with a better 2023. In 2024 it broke down as interest rates went through a cycle, and higher rates and federal tax disruption have interrupted the recovery once more.
Policy Shocks That Rattled Investors
Several Victorian policies hurt investor confidence:
- A land tax threshold change
- A vacant land tax
- A short stay accommodation levy of 7%
- Over 150 rental reforms
Take the land tax. For most investors buying below a million dollars, it is roughly $1,000 to $2,000 a year. It's annoying, but not a deal breaker. The real damage is the confidence shock, because people hear about it rather than research it and decide they won't invest there.
Run the numbers and the picture changes. Add land tax, council rates and strata fees together, and Victoria is still more affordable than some other areas. Brisbane strata schemes carry management rights fees, cyclone insurance in places like Darwin and Cairns costs far more than land tax, and some Gold Coast council rates are proportionately much higher.
Scarring From COVID
The CBD took a very long time to recover, and with no one going in, there was no economic circulation. Small businesses copped it, because you can't live off JobKeeper. I also think there is real mental scarring from such a long lockdown, and people are only now starting to shake it off.
This is a Melbourne story. Regional markets such as Ballarat and Geelong have performed very nicely, because they weren't trapped in that COVID era and benefited from people leaving.
The Case for Buying in Melbourne Now
Weak demand creates low confidence, and low confidence creates weak growth. I don't believe that story lasts forever.
Buying Value, Not Growth
To become wealthy from real estate, you need to buy problems, and Melbourne is a problem marketplace. The first way to create capital growth is deal growth, and the best way to get a deal is to go to a market with a problem and pay less.
I just bought a property in Melbourne at around 12% below valuation. That created around $140,000 on purchase. I'm not buying growth here, I'm buying location. When markets skyrocket, the best locations become unaffordable. When you're early, you get the best pockets.
I wouldn't buy anything in Melbourne, though. Be specific about the locations where you can find value.
What Your Money Buys
For around a million dollars, you can pick up city views about five kilometres from the city. That same real estate in Brisbane, Perth or Sydney today would be two million. Melbourne's median property value was $131,000 in 1996 and is now well over a million dollars.
I also believe in the long run. Of the major urban areas, only Melbourne has the land to home 20 million people, and I think it could be a very large city by 2100 or 2200. Seventy-one percent of Victoria's growth is driven by migration.
Rising Yields
Many investors sold out of Victoria. Fewer landlords means fewer rentals, which improves conditions for those who stay. Some apartment yields are starting to hit 6%, a telltale sign the assets are underpriced. Fewer rental bonds at the bond board is how we know landlords are leaving. That is counter-cyclical buying.
Foreign Money
Both sides of politics are talking about easing land tax, and there is talk of allowing foreign investment back in without the extra land tax flagged by the Property Council. Globally, Melbourne looks very underpriced next to London, New York and Singapore, and that money could stimulate activity and jobs.
What the Election Could Change
The Labor candidate wants to remove the land tax that the previous premier introduced. The opposition has also said it will roll it back. So whoever wins, there should be a clearer picture on land tax after the election, and it should be rolled back over the next couple of years.
I'd prefer to see politicians stand by their policies rather than repeal them when they become unpopular. Still, removing a major irritant could encourage more people to invest in Victoria.
I don't know what will happen at the election. Whether or not green shoots appear, I'm still investing there, because I love buying value. Based on my analysis of the 18-year property cycle, Sydney and Melbourne should be the best value on the recovery food chain of the next cycle, which runs from 2027 to 2045.
If you are a Victorian, have a think about where your state is headed. Look at the mood in Brisbane or on the Gold Coast. Life can be a lot better, and a bit of change might build back the household wealth that is lacking compared to other states.
